Renters have tougher time accumulating wealth than owners: RBC economist

Renters face daunting limitations of their makes an attempt to construct wealth as they’re pressured to dedicate an growing share of their earnings to conserving a roof over their head, mentioned an RBC report out Thursday.

The report by economist Carrie Freestone provides to a rising physique of analysis portray a stark image of the wealth divide between renters and owners.

Householders have seen their web value develop from 9 instances family disposable earnings to 13 instances since 2010, whereas for renters, web wealth grew from three to three.5 instances over the identical interval.

And whereas in 1999, renters devoted about 25% of take-home pay to housing prices in contrast with 23% for owners, in 2022 renters spent 29% on housing in contrast with 21% for owners.

The hole has widened though renters’ incomes have risen on the identical tempo as owners, mentioned Freestone. In the meantime, owners are additionally accumulating residence fairness with their housing funds. 

Final 12 months was even worse for renters, who went from increased financial savings charges through the pandemic to not having sufficient to cowl the payments, based on RBC.

Renters collectively spent almost 9 per cent greater than they earned in disposable earnings in 2023, whereas owners saved seven per cent of their take-home pay, the report mentioned.

“The third quarter of 2023 was the turning level when each owners and renters noticed declines in web wealth. However renters have undoubtedly been hit the toughest,” mentioned Freestone.

The tightening squeeze makes it tougher to save lots of for a down cost, she added. 

“Canadian renters are getting squeezed greater than owners, making residence possession an much more distant dream. This threatens renters’ path to accumulating wealth — which might exacerbate inequality over the long term.”

The report follows one from TD final October that additionally highlighted the stark divide in wealth accumulation between renters and owners.

The TD report led by Beata Caranci discovered the common web value of householders born between 1955 and 1964 had reached greater than $1.4 million, 6.3 instances increased than the wealth of non-homeowners born throughout the identical time.

The $1.2 million wealth hole between the 2 had grown from a spot of just below $500,000 in 2005.

“Wealth inequality is mostly a narrative that differentiates Canadians who’re owners versus those that are usually not,” mentioned Caranci within the report.

The divergent paths of child boomers who have been owners versus renters is more likely to play out worse for younger folks in the present day, she mentioned.

“The present era of younger Canadians is more likely to not simply repeat, however intensify the narrative of wealth inequality throughout housing strains with affordability now at its worst stage in a long time.”

She mentioned that there are various long-standing insurance policies that disproportionately profit owners, together with the capital features exemption, partial GST rebate on new homeownership, the first-time homebuyers tax credit score, renovation tax credit and others.

“The financial savings and investing panorama is so closely skewed towards housing as a result of the housing system itself is designed to perpetuate inequality between owners and non-owners, from zoning that prioritizes single-family houses to tax insurance policies that subsidize possession.”

This report by The Canadian Press was first printed March 14, 2024.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Read More